1  Caroline Thwing    +  Nelson Beebe (4 Apr 1821 Chardon, Geauga Co, OH – 9 Oct 1866 ChardibmGeauga Co, OH)      2  Alvaro Dewitt Beebe (14 Nov 1849 Chardon, Geauga Co, OH – 29 Feb 1932 Green River, Emery Co, UT)         +  Sarah Ann Hossler             3  Robert Wesley Beebe (3 Dec 1884 Ainsworth, Brown Co, NE – 2 Aug 1965 CA)               +  Edna Pearl Skillman