1  David H. Butterbaugh    +  Catherine Long       2  Emauel S. Butterbaugh (9 Jul 1840 MD – 16 Apr 1885)         +  Margaret Ann Virginia Fahrney (18 Mar 1845 MD – 28 Sep 1933)            3  Emma Alice Butterbaugh (29 Apr 1863 – 26 Jul 1863)            3  Unknown Butterbaugh (29 Apr 1863 – 29 Apr 1863)            3  Melvin Ellsworth Butterbaugh (10 Jun 1865 – 14 Mar 1870)            3  David Alva Butterbaugh (16 Jan 1868 Lincoln, Ogle Co, IL – 2 Nov 1944)               +  Amanda Ellen Dusing (25 Nov 1874 Buffalo, Ogle Co, IL – 3 Sep 1956)            3  Samuel Marion Butterbaugh (9 Nov 1870 – 14 Jan 1880)            3  Charles Martin Butterbaugh (9 May 1873 – 5 Feb 1950)               +  Nancy Dollie Miller (1874 Canada – )               +  Josephine Bush (1887 – 1972)            3  Susan Mary Butterbaugh (12 Mar 1875 – 23 Sep 1906)               +  Ira Hahn (1879 – 1966)            3  Ora May Butterbaugh (21 Aug 1877 Polo, Ogle Co, IL – 19 Nov 1949 Dixon, Lee Co, IL)               +  William B. Plum (17 Feb 1878 Lincoln, Ogle Co, IL – 1942)            3  Savilla C. Butterbaugh (24 Nov 1879 Lincoln, Ogle Co, IL – 7 Dec 1948)               +  Jonas Leslie Rowland (1874 MD – )            3  Willard Arthur Butterbaugh (16 Apr 1882 – 27 Jul 1942)               +  Emma Lila Spencer (9 Sep 1887 – 26 Jun 1977)            3  Harvey E. Butterbaugh (4 Oct 1884 – 26 Jul 1951)               +  Orpha Gilbert (23 Jan 1894 – 23 Nov 1952)