1  William Osbaugh    +  Hannah Ruthraugh       2  Ida Osbaugh (1862 PA – 1943)         +  Victor H. Bovey (6 Mar 1856 IL – 18 Jan 1916)            3  Clayton E. Bovey (Mar 1884 IL – 1936)            3  William F. Bovey (Aug 1889 IL – )            3  Maude E. Bovey (Mar 1883 IL – 1960)               +  Wilbur C. Miller (1896 – 1984)            3  Abigail Bovey (Jul 1891 IL – )               +  Unknown Baker